As I wrote yesterday, my goals as written have not been going as planned. That requires some rethinking. And it isn’t just rethinking the goals, it’s rethinking where I’m at and what I’m doing. I was looking through my books today seeking goals that are a little more specific and will help me make these changes in my life. What I found was that I want to skip ahead. I want to say, “Yeah, self acceptance is cool and I’ll get to that after I make all these changes and lose weight.”

You know what that is? That’s diet thinking.

What’s wrong with dieting? Well, dieting is part of what got me here. Starve then binge. Trying to follow someone else’s rules. Learning not to listen to my body. Hating myself for not being able to stick to diets. Seeing myself as weak. Flawed. Bad. Generalizing that thinking to believe that not only am I a failure for not following diets and losing and keeping off weight, but that I’m a failure as a person. Diets don’t work. They seem to work because I can lose weight on them – but they aren’t real life. Diets end. Starting a new diet, I always am looking at the end when I can go back to eating whatever I like.

Some call it a lifestyle change. My lap-band program does that. But that program is still just a diet, regulating what you eat and when. And ultimately, although I had been really successful, it wasn’t something I could stick with. At the time, it didn’t seem that hard – but like any diet, there were “good” and “bad” foods and you need to weigh and measure everything and calorie expectations were around 800 calories. We were advised never to veer off the eating plan. If you ate even that one bite of the dessert you craved, you wouldn’t be able to stop. And that’s probably true, but not for the reasons we were told. In my view, it was just the same as any diet – go off the diet and it’s damn hard to get back on. It’s out of balance.

Ah, but it’s tempting. The new trendy diet, the fast solution, the promises that this one is different. It sounds so easy to have someone else tell you what to eat and how much and when. And even the Overcoming Overeating guidelines can become a diet.


On this very common diet, you set up the Overcoming Overeating guidelines as rules which you believe you “must” follow. When you don’t, you feel like a failure. The Overcoming Overeating “diet” sounds something like this: “I am going to eat only from stomach hunger,” “I’m not ready to get rid of my scale or my small clothes, so obviously I’m not doing this right,” or “I should be looking at myself in the mirror, but I hate what I see.” As we’ve said in previous columns, the process of nondieting is so profoundly different than anything you have done before that it is difficult to comprehend that although the guidelines are firm, the path towards ending body hatred and dieting is unique for each individual. The process of nondieting is a quintessentially human process and therefore has nothing to do with achieving a state of perfection.


So what am I going to do? Slow down. Go back to the beginning. Read. Think. Stop trying to approach this as something I can do perfectly in a few weeks. The key is, like always, keep moving forward.

For now, I’m going to continue working on my goals of decreasing distractions. I may try to eat without distractions, or with less distractions, for dinner only for a while. I think I need to get comfortable with it – right now, it drives me nuts to not be doing something else while eating. And why? Maybe I need to find that out.

I’m going to try to be paying attention to my body and at least observing when I’m eating from head hunger and maybe even figuring out why.

I’m also going to keep including some of those challenges to clean out my closet and to do creative things. I plan to write more about what I’m reading and work on challenges as I find them.

Everyone is different and I’m not saying that anyone else should be following this plan. And this plan may change as I get a better handle on where I am now.


5 thoughts on “rethinking”

  1. Setting goals and reaching them is powerful, so moving forward one step at a time makes sense. The objectives don’t have to relate to food at all. So, I have a question: you and I are alone and eat alone. When they talk about eating with no distractions, what about those times that we eat/talk with friends or family? Does that count? How do we avoid ALL other activities while we eat, unless we put ourselves in solitary confinement? 🙂


    1. I think the objectives need to be mostly not about food and weight at this point. In fact, I want to be healthier and happier and I may need to let go of the weight issue. I need to be happy with who I am.

      Your question is the same one I asked during the LMWL challenge. Sarah did not answer me. As far as I could tell, eating with other people was not considered a distraction. That feels unreasonable to me. Living alone and eating alone is hard enough. I probably eat less if I have absolutely no distractions as I rush through what I’m eating and just want it over with. That doesn’t feel natural. So I will still be searching for a balance that works for me.


  2. What about choosing one distraction to be your dining companion? Like, tomorrow night, you might choose to read a book (but put away your phone, shut off the computer, and hide the TV remote). Then your next meal might be eaten in front of the TV (but your book is in the other room, your phone and computer are both turned off). This way, you don’t have multiple distractions. Also, when you finish the portion of food you start with, you can say, “After I finish 3 more pages, I’ll take another helping,” or, “at the next commercial I’ll decide if I want more.” This helps me pay attention to my food and my hunger cues without getting bored (and sometimes resentful) during mealtimes. Although now my mealtime companion is usually my baby, and mealtime is over when he looses patience with me eating & not playing… then if I need more, I grab it during naptime / after bedtime. So, maybe another solution is to borrow a baby? 🙂


    1. Hmmm. Perhaps I could feed my cat one bite at a time while I eat? Not going to borrow a baby!

      I agree, limiting distractions – choosing one – is probably my best way to baby step my way to change. First step will be not eating in my office. I like your idea about setting some time frame before I take extra food.

      I’ve been really grumpy the past few days so I haven’t actually tried this yet. Why do I take out my frustrations on myself?


      1. It’s been kind of a grumpy week for me too :-/ Just be patient with yourself.

        (That said, sometimes I throw a private tantrum, and it feels so silly do to so that I usually end up at least smiling.)


Comments are closed.